The end result is denying necessary medical care to the most severely affected children.
House Bill 1570 — The Save Adolescents From Experimentation (safe) Act
— has passed the Arkansas House. It looks like the Alliance Defending Freedom boilerplate outlawing medical care for gender incongruent kids.
Never mind that the clinical practice guidelines of the American Academy of Pediatricsand the Pediatric Endocrine Society are based on the gender-affirming care model. Republicans in the Arkansas legislature know best. Or so they believe.
Yet we all know what this is really all about. Kids will die so that these legislators can defend scripture.
And just who are these mental giants capable of challenging medical science?
State Senator Alan Clark is the assistant manager (“VP”) of his family’s hardware store. Presumably selling space heaters makes someone qualified to legislate the care of a medical condition.
State Representative Robin Lundstrum is a property manager. Is that not sufficient erudition to outlaw puberty blockers?
These folks are not too swift when it comes to arithmetic. Behold:
“For natal adult males, prevalence ranges from 0.005% to 0.014%, and for natal females, from 0.002% to 0.003%.”
Actually, according to the American Pyschatric Association about 0.3% of adults are transgender. It’s probably closer to 0.5%. I’ll bet that neither Clark nor Lundstrum had sufficient intellectual curiosity to check if for themselves or they are confused by percentages expressed in decimal form.
The legislators present the usual excuse for inflicting conservative Christianity on everyone:
One more time. Persistence of the condition is a function of its severity. Yes, most children desist. However, desisters never transition in the first place. Severity dictates persistence. These folks do not understand what “gender nonconforming” means as those kids do not transition.
Virtually every paragraph presents a misstatement of medical fact:
Puberty blockers have been vigorously studied for decades. They are deemed safe and effective for numerous conditions including cancers and precocious puberty.
According to research comparing gender incogruent adolescents who received puberty blockers with those who did not receive the medication: Those who underwent puberty suppression had lower odds of lifetime suicidal ideation and severe psychological distress compared to those who wanted the treatment but did not receive it.
This aligns with research out of Harvard Medical School. Any exposure to gender identity conversion efforts results in a lifetime of adverse mental health consequences.
I touched on just a few issues. The findings are loaded with BS including efforts to convince people that children are candidates for gender confirmation surgery. They are not.
An adolescent receiving puberty blockers or cross-sex hormones is being treated by a team of qualified clinicians. The patient and their parents are acquainted with all of the benefits and consequences of hormone therapy.
Common sense dictates that these decisions should be made by patients, their parents and qualified medical personnel. Senator-Hardware-Store and Representative-Property-Manager are as qualified as they would be to author laws regarding the treatment of a pediatric cancers.
The obvious difference is that chemotherapy doesn’t present a contradiction with Genesis 1:27. If it did there is no doubt that they would deem themselves qualified.